View source for Penser ensemble l'espace et le temps (Thinking of Space and Time Together)

{{Infobox paper
| title = Penser ensemble l\'espace et le temps (Thinking of Space and Time Together)
| url = [http://www.naturalphilosophy.org/pdf/abstracts/abstracts_6109.pdf Link to paper]
| author = [[Bernard Guy]]
| keywords = [[space; time; movement; thinking by substance; thinking by relation; relativity theory; uncertainty; incompleteness; three-dimensional time parameter]]
| published = 2010
| journal = [[None]]
| num_pages = 17
}}

'''Read the full paper''' [http://www.naturalphilosophy.org/pdf/abstracts/abstracts_6109.pdf here]

==Abstract==

The foundations of the time and space concepts must be discussed, not inside a thinking of  substance (each of the two concepts is then defined by a series of characters of its own) but  inside a thinking of relation (each concept is defined in opposition to the other). We can speak  of an opposition between spatial and temporal relations, or between relative immobility and  mobility relations (relations are defined between the material points, or elements, of the  world). We are thus led to the movement concept to which we give a "primary" character.  Space-time duality is not based on a duality of substances, but on the multiplicity of the  elements of the world, and the possible sharing (based on their relative movements) of their  mutual relations, between two (or more) groups. This sharing does not avoid a number of  conceptual and logical difficulties and the need for a (at least provisional) stop, and the facing  of situations containing some uncertainty, incompleteness, recursivity, contradiction? All  such situations are already discussed about quantum mechanics and one finds them in the  thinking of space and time. This approach also makes appear, within a very general abstract  structure, the steps, or conditions, for thinking by relation.  Two parts of applications are proposed:

* first to physics; several topics may be discussed within the present approach: the  identification that we can do between time and movement is not without practical  consequences. It leads us to use three coordinates to construct the time parameter, not in  supplement to spatial coordinates, but as three of them, and that one must add to those of the  spatial points: they correspond to the coordinates of a particular point, measured in the same  spatial frame, the movement of which we use to define time. This has many implications for  the functioning of the formalism (writing general conservation laws in physics, Lorentz  transformations, Maxwell's equations; modification of the equations of gravity ...).
* second, application to culture in the large; the time paradoxes may be discussed and we  propose a solution. The difficulties that arise (existence of a multiplicity of times, meaning of  the past / present / future categories) are clarified by two statements: - the multiplicity of  relations generates a multiplicity of times and ? a single time parameter must necessarily be  chosen in order to communicate but it is conventional.

We conclude about the question set by the title of the paper: can we think of space and time  ?together?? Yes, at least provisionally, by means of the mental image that links them within  the movement. Yes, only for a moment, within an ephemeral acceptation of contradiction,  before a compulsory "stop." Let us remember Aristotle's Physics indeed: "we must stop."  Only this stop allows us to build our knowledge, and after it, we no longer tolerate  contradiction. But what we can highlight now, is the conventional, fragile, never ended nature  of this stop, along an infinite transhumance, which constantly asks us to renovate our way to  speak of the world. More generally, we propose to see, in any relation, a spatial aspect (the  gap between the two terms of the relation) and a temporal aspect (the travel along the path  that connects them).

[[Category:Scientific Paper|penser ensemble l 'espace et le temps thinking space time]]

[[Category:Relativity|penser ensemble l 'espace et le temps thinking space time]]