Roger B Angel: Difference between revisions
expand: career, McGill theses, publications, death; remove the Worldwide List of Dissident Scientists tag - he defended relativity and has no dissident connection |
add an Education section (wiki convention: education gets its own heading, not folded into Career) |
||
| Line 12: | Line 12: | ||
'''He was not a critic of relativity.''' His book defends the theory and directs its criticism at other philosophers — at Adolf [[Adolf Grünbaum|Grünbaum]]'s conventionalism about simultaneity, at Kuhn's and Feyerabend's thesis of incommensurability, and at operationalist and a priorist readings of physics. He explicitly rejected both the view that special relativity is self-contradictory and the neo-Lorentzian revival of the aether, writing of the latter that it "amounts to both praising and violating the theory at the same time". His inclusion in this catalogue appears to be an artefact of a bulk import of relativity-related books rather than a considered classification; the point is set out on the [[Relativity: The Theory and Its Philosophy#Why it appears on this wiki|book's page]]. | '''He was not a critic of relativity.''' His book defends the theory and directs its criticism at other philosophers — at Adolf [[Adolf Grünbaum|Grünbaum]]'s conventionalism about simultaneity, at Kuhn's and Feyerabend's thesis of incommensurability, and at operationalist and a priorist readings of physics. He explicitly rejected both the view that special relativity is self-contradictory and the neo-Lorentzian revival of the aether, writing of the latter that it "amounts to both praising and violating the theory at the same time". His inclusion in this catalogue appears to be an artefact of a bulk import of relativity-related books rather than a considered classification; the point is set out on the [[Relativity: The Theory and Its Philosophy#Why it appears on this wiki|book's page]]. | ||
==Education== | |||
* MA, philosophy, McGill University, 1961 — thesis on Henri Poincaré's theory of conventionalism | |||
* PhD, philosophy, McGill University, 1969 — thesis titled ''Relativity and Covariance'' | |||
==Career== | ==Career== | ||
His 1961 thesis was on Poincaré's conventionalism — a subject he would return to twenty years later from the opposite direction — and his 1969 doctoral thesis became the core of chapter 10 of his book. He acknowledged Mario Bunge as "my teacher … It was he who first taught me how to understand science and how to philosophize about it", and his work belongs squarely to Bunge's scientific-realist school, though he disagreed with Bunge on the status of general covariance. | |||
He taught at Concordia University in Montreal, thanking colleagues in its physics and mathematics departments in the preface to his book, which is dated Montreal, June 1979. | He taught at Concordia University in Montreal, thanking colleagues in its physics and mathematics departments in the preface to his book, which is dated Montreal, June 1979. | ||
Latest revision as of 20:31, 22 July 2026
Roger B. Angel | |
|---|---|
| Residence | Montreal, QC, Canada |
| Nationality | Canadian |
| Known for | Relativity: The Theory and Its Philosophy (1980) |
| Scientific career | |
| Fields | Philosopher |
| Institutions | Concordia University, Montreal |
Roger B. Angel was a Canadian philosopher of science at Concordia University in Montreal, and the author of Relativity: The Theory and Its Philosophy (Pergamon, 1980), a scientific-realist treatment of the philosophical foundations of special and general relativity.
He was not a critic of relativity. His book defends the theory and directs its criticism at other philosophers — at Adolf Grünbaum's conventionalism about simultaneity, at Kuhn's and Feyerabend's thesis of incommensurability, and at operationalist and a priorist readings of physics. He explicitly rejected both the view that special relativity is self-contradictory and the neo-Lorentzian revival of the aether, writing of the latter that it "amounts to both praising and violating the theory at the same time". His inclusion in this catalogue appears to be an artefact of a bulk import of relativity-related books rather than a considered classification; the point is set out on the book's page.
Education
- MA, philosophy, McGill University, 1961 — thesis on Henri Poincaré's theory of conventionalism
- PhD, philosophy, McGill University, 1969 — thesis titled Relativity and Covariance
Career
His 1961 thesis was on Poincaré's conventionalism — a subject he would return to twenty years later from the opposite direction — and his 1969 doctoral thesis became the core of chapter 10 of his book. He acknowledged Mario Bunge as "my teacher … It was he who first taught me how to understand science and how to philosophize about it", and his work belongs squarely to Bunge's scientific-realist school, though he disagreed with Bunge on the status of general covariance.
He taught at Concordia University in Montreal, thanking colleagues in its physics and mathematics departments in the preface to his book, which is dated Montreal, June 1979.
Concordia's alumni magazine recorded the death of Roger Angel, former professor of philosophy of science at the university, on 22 July 2022 at the age of 89. The notice gives the name without the middle initial; the identification rests on the match of institution, field and dates, and should be treated as very likely rather than certain.
Publications
- "Explanation and Prediction: A Plea for Reason", Philosophy of Science 34, 276–282 (1967).
- "Relativity and Covariance", in Mario Bunge (ed.), The Methodological Unity of Science, D. Reidel, 1973, 53–68.
- Relativity: The Theory and Its Philosophy, Pergamon Press, 1980.
- Review of Roberto Torretti, Philosophy of Geometry from Riemann to Poincaré, Dialogue 21, 384–391 (1982).