Bridge From Nowhere: A Story of Space, Motion, and the Structure of Matter
 | |
| Author | William Day |
|---|---|
| Published | 1989 |
| Publisher | House of Talos Publishers, East Lansing, Michigan |
| Pages | 288 |
| ISBN | 0935970010 |
Bridge From Nowhere: A Story of Space, Motion, and the Structure of Matter is a 1989 book by the chemist William Day. It is the founding statement of what he later called holistic physics: the claim that matter and motion are inseparable, that motion is a structural feature of matter rather than something matter does, and that the material world is built as a three-storey hierarchy of orbital systems — particles, atoms, gravitating systems — each obeying the same pattern at its own scale.
The book is unusual in this literature for who wrote it. Day was not an outsider to peer review: a decade earlier he had published Genesis on Planet Earth, an origin-of-life book taken up by Yale University Press for its Bio-Origins series with a foreword by Lynn Margulis, and reviewed by such figures as Sidney W. Fox and Hyman Hartman. Bridge From Nowhere is what happened when he turned the same interest — how ordered structure arises out of a featureless beginning — from biology to physics.
Its thesis is stated on the jacket:
In this remarkable book the author challenges the traditional definition of motion. He contends that matter and motion are fundamentally inseparable. At each level of matter's hierarchy — particles, atoms, gravitational systems — motion is a structural feature; and as objects move in space, they behave as components conforming to a basic composition of kinematic systems.
— Jacket copy, Bridge From Nowhere (1989)
The argument
Motion as structure
The book's point of departure is a complaint about what physics chose to measure. Dynamics treats motion as something that happens to a body when a force is applied, and describes it with mass, momentum and energy. Day's contention is that this gets the order backwards: at every level of matter, motion is already there as part of the thing's construction. An electron in an atom is not a particle that happens to be moving; the motion is the atom's structure. Take the motion away and there is no object left to be at rest.
He drew from this a distinction he kept for the rest of his life — that there are two physics, not one. "There are, therefore, two physics: the dynamics of causality and the holistic physics of systems… Holism is the overview; when we measure something we use dynamics." Dynamics, on this account, is not wrong but derivative: it measures nature's response to our interference with it rather than nature's own arrangement.
The orbital hierarchy
The organising claim is that matter has exactly three structural storeys, and that each is the same kind of thing — an orbital system, in which a nuclear body creates the conditions around which a system assembles, and in which the system's properties belong to the assembly rather than to its parts. Particles, atoms and gravitating systems repeat one pattern across some forty orders of magnitude.
Day later attached a scaling law to the hierarchy: the density of a system's enclosed field is inversely proportional to the size of the system, so that field density multiplied by volume is constant. "The space content of all orbital systems is equal" — from a nucleon to a solar system.
The geometry underlying this he called kinematic geometry. In the book-era formulation the principles were four: that distance, velocity and time are interrelated by d = vt; that all lines of motion in space are closed; that orbital lengths are absolute and self-contained; and that displacement by force translates into orbital change. By 2010 he had compressed them into three laws of motion:
1. A body in space will move spontaneously to equalize its gravitational field and remain centered in ambient space.
2. Unobstructed motion in space is potentially closed and orbital.
3. Motion is an integral part of structural matter.— William Day, "Holistic Physics in a Self-Organizing Universe" (2010)
The first of these carries his account of gravity, and it is not an account of a force. "Gravity is not a force of attraction between masses, it is simply the effect of spontaneous motion due to a universe that is self-organizing." A body falls because it is settling into the arrangement its field requires, not because it is being pulled.
Space, and the bridge from nowhere
Behind the hierarchy stands Day's conception of space, which is where the title points. Space, for him, is real but nonmaterial — a medium with cohesion but none of the features we associate with physical existence, and the carrier of light waves and fields. Fields are "reverberations in surrounding space by the structural motion of particles", and a gravitational field is a weakening of space's cohesion that retards the velocity of light. For observational support he leaned on the Sagnac (1913) and Michelson–Gale (1925) experiments, which he later reprinted as an appendix to A New Physics.
He also set a floor to the physical world. A wave cannot oscillate faster than it propagates — one wave must move before the next can form — so there is a shortest possible wavelength, which he put at 1/c, about 0.3 × 10−10 cm. Below that threshold nothing can be detected or measured at all. He noted that the photon whose relativistic mass equals that of an electron and positron has a wavelength of 2.17 × 10−10 cm, "only slightly larger", and treated the near-coincidence as significant rather than accidental.
This then is the boundary between the physical world as we know it and virtual space from which matter and energy emerged.
— William Day, "What is Missing From Physical Theory"
That "virtual space" is, on the reading the later work supports, the nowhere of the title, and the hierarchy of orbital systems is the bridge across it — the ladder by which photons became particles, particles atoms, and atoms gravitating systems. Day was explicit about the theological shape of the conclusion and untroubled by it: space is "the source-spring from which matter and energy originated", and "we can then reason that creation actually did occur out of nothing." (Day never glossed the title in print; this reading is drawn from the later papers rather than from the book itself.)
Particles
The book's model of subatomic structure is the part its jacket promised would produce "astonishing results", and it is a direct rival to the quark model rather than a modification of it. On Day's scheme a proton or neutron consists of a nucleus of charged neutrinos surrounded by three shells of virtual photons — he insisted that neutrinos and antineutrinos, which he called positrinos and negatrinos, carry electric charge. The neutron he gave as four positive and five negative neutrinos inside the three photon shells; the odd ninth is what makes the free neutron unstable, and its ejection is why protons and electrons exist in exactly equal numbers. The electron itself he treated as a cyclized photon, stabilised at a radius of e2/mc2.
Day himself regarded the 1989 particle model as unfinished. The sequel, Bridge From Nowhere II: The Photonic Origin of Matter (1996), exists precisely to replace it: "the first book contained the basic concepts of a new physics, but with an incomplete model for particles."
Place in Day's work
Bridge From Nowhere is the first and the load-bearing volume of a sequence, and Day's later papers cite it as the source of the orbital hierarchy. It was followed by Bridge From Nowhere II: The Photonic Origin of Matter (1996), which completed the particle model and argued against quarks; Holistic Physics (1997); A New Physics (2000), subtitled "a revision of space, motion, and the structure of matter" — an explicit rewrite of this book's own subtitle, and the fullest statement of the system; and How Life Began (2002), which returns to origin-of-life questions after twenty-three years. Between 2010 and 2013 he presented four papers to the Natural Philosophy Alliance restating the framework, including Holistic Physics in a Self-Organizing Universe, The Orbital Systems of Matter and Its Origin and a critique of Hawking and Mlodinow's The Grand Design.
The publishing history is worth recording plainly. House of Talos was Day's own imprint in East Lansing, Michigan — its entire catalogue consists of three of his own books, including a family genealogy. The later physics titles were issued by Rhombics and the Foundation for New Directions of Cambridge, Massachusetts, both run by Marvin Solit, an osteopath whose foundation worked in holistic health and sacred geometry. The physics, in other words, never had a physics publisher.
Reception
Bridge From Nowhere was noticed once, in Choice — the American Library Association's academic-library selection journal — in December 1990. Beyond that the book, and the four that followed it, drew essentially nothing: no review in any physics journal, no citations in the scientific literature, and no engagement from either the mainstream or the wider dissident community. The only substantial commentary on the system came from within the circle that published it — Hal Fox in New Energy News and the energy-medicine writer Jim Oschman, whose review appeared on the publisher's own site.
The contrast with Day's earlier career is stark, and is the most interesting fact about him. Genesis on Planet Earth travelled from self-publication in 1979 to a British trade science house in 1981, to Yale University Press in 1984, to an Arabic translation issued by Iraq's Ministry of Culture in 1989. It drew at least nine reviews in the scientific literature — including one in Nature in March 1985, and notices by Sidney W. Fox in The Quarterly Review of Biology, by Hyman Hartman in Precambrian Research, and in Origins of Life by Mitchell Rambler and Lynn Margulis, who would go on to write the foreword to the Yale edition. It has accumulated something on the order of fifty scholarly citations. Day had also published in Science and four times in Biochimica et Biophysica Acta, on petroleum geochemistry and on the blood-clotting factor V.
The same author, writing on physics, reached one library-journal notice and no citations at all. Whether that reflects on the physics or on its reception is exactly the question this wiki exists to keep open.
Related work on this wiki
Day's hierarchy of self-similar orbital systems places him near several other research programmes catalogued here, though he appears not to have engaged with them directly. The claim that a single structural pattern repeats from the nucleon to the galaxy is shared with the infinite-hierarchy tradition of Glenn Borchardt and with fractal and scale-relativity cosmologies; the treatment of space as a real, cohesive, nonmaterial medium places him in the Aether literature, though he avoided the word; and his rejection of gravity as a force of attraction in favour of spontaneous self-organising motion runs parallel to, but is distinct from, the push-gravity models collected under Push Gravity. His model of nucleons as neutrino cores in photon shells is a direct alternative to the quark model, a position also taken in a number of papers under Nuclear Structure.
See also
- William Day
- Bridge From Nowhere II: The Photonic Origin of Matter
- A New Physics
- Holistic Physics
- How Life Began
- Aether
- Natural Philosophy Alliance
Links to Purchase Book
External links
- Day's website, Non-Newtonian Physics (archived, 2000–2006) — the fullest connected statement of holistic physics online.
- "Holistic Physics in a Self-Organizing Universe" — contains the Three Laws of Kinematic Geometry.
- Library of Congress catalogue record for this book.