Experimentum Crucis for Magnetic Interaction

From Natural Philosophy Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Scientific Paper
Title Experimentum Crucis for Magnetic Interaction
Read in full Link to paper
Author(s) Stewart Ian Wells
Keywords {{{keywords}}}
Published 2010
Journal Proceedings of the NPA
Volume 7
No. of pages 4
Pages 612-619

Read the full paper here


The investigation of the long-standing controversy over the precise formulation of the magnetic interaction between steady currents (or between uniformly moving charges) is re-opened. An experimental technique is proposed whereby the distinction between the Ampere-Weber ?central force' formulation and the Grassmann-Lorentz ?normal force' formulation can be demonstrated decisively within a modestly equipped laboratory. Although no preference is advanced on theoretical grounds, a confirmation of the ?normal force' law would have notable consequences for theory: the third law of motion could only be satisfied through reaction against a background medium, and the possibility of a ?jetless' propulsion system is thereby suggested. It is also argued that the ?longitudinal' portion of the original Ampere force law is nonetheless compatible with, and perhaps necessary for, either possible outcome.